| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sarita Devi Facing AIBA 'Life Ban' -
We ask YOUR view - 'Is this Justice'?
by Michael O'Neill
November 13, 2014
Send in your Comments |
|
|
|
|
|
(NOV 13) Outrage today in
Indian boxing circles as news came through that the AIBA was
considering a life ban following Sarita Devi’s refusal to accept
the bronze medal she had ‘won’ when ‘defeated’ by the host
nation’s Jina Park at the recent Asiad in Incheon, Korea.
We ask you, our readers, for YOUR view on the AIBA’s proposed
ban. We ask you, our readers, for YOUR view on the AIBA’s
proposed ban. You can contact us as usual by emailing
wban100@aol.com or
via our Facebook pages.
If you have strong views on the subject, either way, you might
also wish to make your views known to the AIBA :
info@aiba.org
Here we bring you the overnight reaction from Indian media and
Government sources on the comments from AIBA President Dr Ching
Kuo-Wu in Jeju yesterday and subsequently in media interviews.
You will recall that the Eighth edition of the AIBA Women’s
World Championships open in Jeju, South Korea on Sunday and
these latest developments will not be welcomed by boxers, their
coaches or indeed by the AIBA themselves as they seriously
distract attention from the Worlds.
Various news agency reports quote Dr Wu thus:
"She will be heavily punished, there will be zero tolerance. It
was totally unacceptable behaviour for any competition in any
sport, I think her boxing career is finished. Every athlete
should fully respect the decisions of referees and judges. So
this boxer is facing very severe punishment. She has damaged her
own country, India has been damaged,"
"If you accept being the winner, you have to accept being the
loser. If everyone behaved like that, what type of competition
will we have?" he added.
Those comments were echoed again when Dr Wu spoke with “The
Times of India/AP”. As you may recall from our previous updates,
Sandeep Jajodia, President of recently formed AIBA affiliate,
‘Boxing India’, urged the AIBA to revoke Devi's provisional
suspension, saying "It was purely an emotional reaction and not
pre-planned."
"We don't deny that it was disrespectful toward the code of
conduct for athletes but she tendered an unconditional apology,"
according to Jajodia.
AIBA President Wu clearly disagrees.
"I said to them, that (apology) doesn't matter, you need to
think before you act," Wu told the AP. "She probably will be
banned for some time because we want to consider the case that
all the referees and judges' decisions need to be respected."
The Indian Government has condemned the AIBA’s actions.
Response to Dr Wu’s comments came ‘thick and fast’ :
DNA news agency spoke of the Government’s dismay at hearing Dr
Wu’s comments with the country’s sports minister Sarbananda
Sonowal saying that the government would continue to fight for
her.
On Dr CK Wu's statement that 'Sarita's international career may
be over', Sonowal termed it as "unfortunate" and "too harsh" on
the athlete.
"I am really hurt and shocked by what AIBA president has said.
Hearing his comment, I would like to say that the whole ministry
is behind Sarita. I have instructed the Director General Sports
Authority of India to take up the matter with the Boxing India
at the earliest. We want Sarita to get justice. Our government
will continue to fight for her and we ensure full support to the
boxer," said Sonowal.
The Indian Olympic Association (IOA) secretary general Rajeev
Mehta went further and ‘has vowed to take the matter to Court of
Arbitration for Sport (CAS)’.
"Let the decision come. We (IOA) will certainly talk to sports
ministry first before challenging the verdict in CAS," Mehta
told dna on Wednesday.
Sonowal said that the AIBA should have accepted the written
apology of Sarita as her emotional outburst at the podium was
not pre-planned.
"Sarita has already given a written apology to the AIBA and the
Olympic Council of Asia (OCA) has already accepted it. The AIBA
should also let her off and forgive her. This written apology is
sufficient. Her outburst was not pre-planned and I think the
AIBA's decision is too harsh," he said.
And so the anger in India grows….
Should Sarita Devi be suspended for life for her actions in
Incheon? What do you think? We ask you, our readers, for
YOUR view on the AIBA’s proposed ban. You can contact us as
usual by emailing
wban100@aol.com or via our Facebook pages.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|